Most workers would rather have cash than a party this Christmas, and the gap between what they want and what they get is wide. A survey of 1,040 American workers, released on November 9 by career site Zety, found 77% would most like a holiday cash bonus from their employer, but only 34% typically receive one. The holiday cash bonus is the most wanted workplace gift by a long way, yet it remains the exception rather than the rule.
The rest of the wish list tells the same story. Gift cards are the only perk where supply matches demand, at 39% received and 39% wanted. A holiday party is received by 25% of workers but wanted by only 12%, a team meal by 24% against 9% who want one, and company-branded items by 15% against 5%. Extra paid time off is wanted by 24% but received by just 8%. When asked what a gift would need to be worth to feel meaningful, the most common answer was $50 to $99, chosen by 26% of workers.
The stress behind the wish list
The survey also found a harder edge to workplace gifting. About 43% of workers said expectations around holiday gifts cause them financial stress, and 35% have bought or chipped in for a manager’s gift because they felt obliged to. On the positive side, 53% said receiving a holiday gift would make them feel more valued at work, and 35% said it would make them more motivated. The message for employers is that a gift matters, but only if it is the right one.
What employers are getting wrong
The pattern is not limited to the United States. A separate Canadian survey by Employment Hero found 81% of full-time workers there would trade the office holiday party for a cash bonus, with only 13% choosing the party. The advice from Zety’s career expert is to set clear gifting rules and say plainly that gifts are not expected, including collections organised by colleagues. For workers watching holiday gift budgets hold at $708 this year, a cash bonus would land at exactly the right moment, and with BNPL spending hitting records, many households are already borrowing to cover the season. A bonus beats a branded mug every time.

