Two in three people would rather receive a second-hand gift that suits them than a brand-new one they will never use, according to new research from resale marketplace Vinted and YouGov — a finding that could reshape how millions of us shop this Christmas.
The research, covering six countries including the UK and the United States, found that one in two people (56 percent) receives at least one unwanted gift each festive season, 1.7 on average. Over half (57 percent) admit they play it safe when buying presents, and one in three (30 percent) have regretted giving a generic gift instead of something more personal.
The gifts that miss the mark
Asked which presents they had received and not wanted, people named toiletry and grooming sets first (32 percent), then clothing and accessories (31 percent), mugs and kitchenware (28 percent), candles and home décor (27 percent), socks and slippers (24 percent) and perfume or aftershave (23 percent).
The unwanted gifts rarely stay put. In the week after last Christmas, listings of unwanted gifts on Vinted nearly quadrupled, up 283 percent on the week before. Most people try to pass the gift on: 40 percent donate it or give it to someone else or a charity, 28 percent re-gift it and 15 percent sell it. Millennials are the most likely to sell (21 percent), boomers the most likely to donate (44 percent), while Gen Z are most likely to keep it in a drawer (40 percent).
Second-hand is losing its stigma
The good news for gift-givers is that 67 percent would rather have a second-hand gift that suits them than a new one they will not use. A separate survey by resale platform ThredUp points the same way: 55 percent of Americans would rather receive a one-of-a-kind, vintage or hard-to-find secondhand gift than a brand-new mass-produced one, and 62 percent plan to buy secondhand this season.
The Vinted and YouGov survey covered 10,860 adults across the UK, US, France, Germany, the Netherlands and Poland, with fieldwork between October 5 and 14, 2026. Black Friday shoppers hunting for a present that actually lands may find the best answer is not new at all — it is second-hand, and chosen with the recipient in mind.

