Winter heating bills are splitting sharply by fuel this year, with households that burn heating oil facing a bill about 21 percent higher than last winter while homes on natural gas should pay about 9 percent less. The US Energy Information Administration published its 2026-27 Winter Fuels Outlook on October 6, and it forecasts an average winter spend of $2,115 for heating oil homes, up about $370, against $640 for natural gas homes, down about $62.
A second forecast paints a more expensive picture for nearly everyone. The National Energy Assistance Directors Association projects US households will spend an average of $1,030 to heat their homes this winter, an increase of $82, or 8.7 percent, according to UVN News. Either way, the type of fuel in the furnace matters more than the thermostat setting this winter.
Heating oil takes the biggest hit
Heating oil is the outlier. The EIA forecasts the fuel will average $5.26 a gallon this winter, up 34 percent from $3.94 last winter, because crude oil and diesel-type fuels cost more worldwide and US stocks are low going into winter, according to Energy News Beat. About 4.1 million homes burn heating oil, mostly in the Northeast, and they are expected to use about 9 percent less fuel, helped by milder weather forecast for the region.
EIA Administrator Tristan Abbey said relatively high natural gas inventories provide a cushion for heating demand, while households that rely on heating oil face higher prices because distillate markets remain tight. The agency expects national winter temperatures roughly the same as last winter and the prior ten-winter average, but with warmer conditions in the Northeast and much colder weather in the West after an unusually warm winter there.
Gas and propane households catch a break
Roughly half of US households heat mainly with natural gas or propane, and both groups are forecast to spend less than last winter. Natural gas inventories entered the season about 2 percent above the five-year average, and the average household bill is projected at $640 at a retail price of about $13.44 per thousand cubic feet, according to the EIA outlook. Propane households should spend about $1,246, down 3 percent, at $2.52 a gallon.
Homes that heat with electricity face a smaller rise: retail electricity prices are forecast to increase 3 percent to an average of 18.23 cents per kilowatt-hour, lifting average winter electric bills by 4 percent to $1,196. The wild card is the weather. The EIA cautions that a strong El Nino could produce different outcomes and change heating demand and spending, and it updates its forecast each month. Households struggling with bills can ask their state about the federal Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program, which helps with heating costs.


