The 1:24 scale model of Hogwarts on display at Warner Bros. Studio Tour London
Photo: Clement Proust (CapStudio), CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

HBO Harry Potter Clip Divides Fans With New Dumbledore Chant

Spread the love
The 1:24 scale model of Hogwarts on display at Warner Bros. Studio Tour London
Photo: Clement Proust (CapStudio), CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

HBO has released the first full clip from its new Harry Potter series, and fans are already arguing about it. The roughly 90-second scene, titled “The Start-of-Term Banquet,” was shared on Saturday on the official Harry Potter YouTube channel and Instagram, six weeks before the series arrives on Christmas Day.

The clip takes viewers straight into the Great Hall on Harry’s first night at Hogwarts, just after the Sorting ceremony. The students loudly chant Dumbledore’s name and bang their hands on the tables in unison, before John Lithgow’s headmaster snaps his fingers and the four house tables fill with food. A stunned Harry, played by Dominic McLaughlin, asks Ron, played by Alastair Stout, if Dumbledore is mad, a question he put to Percy in the book.

Changes that were never in the book

The clip then ends on a moment that appears in neither the book nor the 2001 film: a private conversation between Dumbledore and Janet McTeer’s Professor McGonagall about Harry and his future. The chant itself is also new. In the books and the original films, the students never chant Dumbledore’s name, and some fans have called the change cringey, while others say it gives the scene noise and energy.

Reviewers have noted the contrast with the 2001 film, which played the feast as a moment of wonder. HBO’s version swaps that for a livelier, more upbeat Great Hall, although the set itself closely resembles its film counterpart. As one report put it, a few minutes of footage rarely shows the whole picture, and judging an eight-episode series on 90 seconds would be unfair.

Christmas Day cannot come soon enough

Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone premieres on December 25 on HBO and HBO Max, with the rest of the eight-episode first season following weekly. HBO is adapting the seven novels at one season per book, and the first teaser, released back in March, drew 277 million views in 48 hours, making it the most-watched trailer the company has ever put out, according to reports.

The clip arrives just as the franchise marks a milestone: the first film opened in cinemas 25 years ago this week, on November 16, 2001. A quarter of a century on, Hogwarts is serving dinner again, and the whole world is watching to see how it tastes.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *